[Video: How to Remake the Big Bang]
Universes going bump in the night
Mortlock and the team, led by graduate
student Stephen Feeney of University College London, searched the best available observations of the cosmic microwave background for signs of bubble universe
collisions, but didn’t find anything conclusive. If two universes had collided, the researchers say, it would have left a circular pattern behind in the
cosmic microwave background.
“If you imagine two ordinary soap bubbles colliding, then the surface where they intersect is going to be a circle, so
that’s the key signature we’re looking for in the CMB,” Mortlock told SPACE.com. “It’s not any old perturbation, it’s circular and it’s got a particular
type of profile. There’s no obvious sort of other thing that could cause this.”
The researchers developed a computer algorithm to analyze CMB
observations for patterns that would fit. In data from NASA’s Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP), the program found four regions in the universe that
were flagged as promising. However, statistical analyses suggested these patterns were likely to be random, resembling the circular shapes of collisions simply
Data from the European
Space Agency’s Planck satellite, which launched in 2009, are expected to be far more detailed than those from WMAP. The Planck measurements are set to be
released in 2013, and the researchers plan to look again, surveying in particular the four areas of interest from this study.
“I think the Feeney et al.
paper is a great first step in trying to seriously look for signals of cosmological bubble collisions,” said astrophysicist Thomas Levi of the University of
British Columbia in Canada, who was not involved in the study. “While I believe the potential exists to detect the presence of other universes, the present
data from WMAP is not likely to be precise enough to make a definitive statement. We will have to wait for data from future CMB experiments, such as the Planck
satellite. The next few years could be quite exciting.”
The universe that’s ‘just right’
idea of other universes out there is mind-bending, but
scientists say in some ways it actually makes sense.
“It helps explain some of the strange coincidences about our own universe,” Mortlock said. “Why is
our universe so amenable to life?”
Many of the fundamental constants in our universe, such as the strength of gravity and the speed of light, seem
perfectly calibrated to produce a universe in which galaxies, stars, planets and even life can form. If any of these constants had been tweaked at all, the
universe would likely be empty, with no stars and no life.
But if our universe is one of many, then the fact that it’s so perfectly tuned for life
isn’t such an unlikely coincidence. [7 Theories on the Origin of
“One possibility is there are multiple different universes with different laws, and some are not right for life and so life doesn’t evolve,
and some are right for life and so creatures evolve and make measurements and ask deep, twisty questions like this,” Mortlock said. “For that reason [the
theory] is very appealing.”
However, the possibility of multiple universes also comes with some unsettling implications. For example, some calculations
suggest that a reality with infinite space and infinite universes would necessarily have to repeat itself sometimes, leading to the conclusion that copies of
Earth and everyone on it exist somewhere else out there.
“Once you open up this can of worms, there’s all sorts of very adventurous thinking on this
sort of thing,” Mortlock said. “If there’s infinitely many universes, then surely there are other copies of you and me having this conversation. It’s hard to
think about, but it’s hard to get around.”
The scientists detailed their study in two research papers published recently in the journals Physical
Review Letters and Physical Review D.